WHY APOSTLES AND PASTORS OFTEN CLASH
Key Takeaways
• Apostles and pastors have different leadership instincts and priorities
• Apostles focus on expansion while pastors focus on care and stability
• These differences are not flaws, they are part of God’s design
• When these gifts work together, the Church becomes healthier and stronger
If you’ve spent any time around church leadership, you may have noticed something that is pretty interesting to watch. Sometimes Apostles and Pastors see things very differently.
In this contrast, one leader wants to move quickly into new territory and the other wants to slow down and make sure the people already inside the community are cared for well.
One is thinking about expansion. The other is thinking about stability. And when those two perspectives collide, tension can appear. But the important thing to understand is that regardless of how people on the outside may view it, this tension isn’t necessarily a problem. In fact, I believe that it is actually part of God’s design.
Two Different Leadership Instincts
Inside the Five-Fold Frontier teaching, I often explain the difference between apostles and pastors using a frontier metaphor.
If you were to imagine a group of pioneers building a new town, the Apostolic leader is the one looking at the open land and saying, “Let’s build something here.” They see opportunity and movement. Their instinct is to establish new communities, launch new initiatives, and move the mission forward.
The Pastoral leader, however, is focused on the people living inside the town. I call this gifting the Town Mayor as they are asking different questions. Are the families healthy? Are the relationships strong? Are people being cared for spiritually and emotionally?
Both perspectives are essential, but they operate with totally different priorities which can cause some pretty serious clashes if they don’t each recognize the strengths of the other and lean into them for the betterment of the entire community.
Expansion vs. Care
See, Apostolic leaders tend to think in terms of mission and expansion. Their mindset naturally moves toward growth, new initiatives, and multiplying what God is doing.
On the other hand, Pastoral leaders think in terms of care and stability. So, they focus on protecting the community, nurturing relationships, and making sure people feel seen, supported, and spiritually healthy.
Please understand that neither of these instincts is wrong. But when they are misunderstood, the apostle may feel the pastor is slowing things down. And the pastor may feel the apostle is moving entirely too fast, when in reality, both are simply trying to serve the same mission.
Why This Tension Can Be Healthy
To help explain why I believe this tension can be both healthy an beneficial, I want you to think about a car for a moment.
If the vehicle only had an accelerator, it would constantly speed up without control. If it only had brakes, it would never move forward. And in a fully working vehicle that is going to get you back and forth from your destination you need both to navigate the changes in both speed and direction that will be required to get to where you’re going safely.
Without oversimplifying, Apostles often function like the accelerator. They push movement, expansion, and new opportunities.
Pastors function like the stabilizing system. They ensure the people inside the community remain healthy and cared for.
When both gifts are respected, the Church moves forward and stays healthy at the same time. This is the key to both gifts working together, as taking new ground means nothing if you don’t have anyone healthy enough to move into it. However, on the other side, living in total health in the same place with no movement creates stagnation and keeps the community from expanding into new territories.
When the Gifts Work Together
The real problem isn’t the tension between these gifts as this is natural and needed for balancing seasons of warfare and expansion with seasons of healthcare and healing.
However, the real problem happens when leaders assume their perspective is the only one that matters.
What I’ve learned over the course of my 28 years in ministry is that Apostles need Pastors…and Pastors need Apostles. Because when these gifts work together, something powerful happens: The Church expands while, at the same time, remaining spiritually healthy.
In this co-operative dynamic, new people continue to be reached without neglecting the people already inside the community. In this place of collaboration, both vision and care begin functioning together. And when that balance exists, the Church reflects the full leadership design that Jesus established.
A Question Worth Considering
Instead of asking which leadership style is right, what might happen if the Church started asking how these different gifts could build together?
Continue the Journey
This conversation is exactly what we explore inside the Five-Fold Frontier teaching at Plain English Academy.
We dive into how these five leadership gifts function, why they sometimes create tension, and how those tensions can actually produce stronger Kingdom communities when leaders learn to work together.
Because the goal isn’t uniformity. The goal is unity.
For more leadership and faith-based teaching like this, explore the resources available inside the Plain English Academy. You can also learn more about the mission behind Plain English on the About page or read additional articles on the Plain English Blog.
Churches and organizations interested in leadership or spiritual development training can also book Pastor Jay to speak.
Continue the Conversation
If this article resonated with you and you want to keep growing in the areas of Marriage, Leadership, and the Five-Fold, we’d love to invite you to join us inside the Plain English Academy.
You can start by joining our free Plain English Academy Community on Facebook, or explore the in-depth courses and hands-on training available through the Academy with Pastor Jay and Pastor Sonia.
❤️ Stronger Marriages
📈 Leadership Development
🔥 Discover Your Calling
Inside the Plain English Academy you’ll find practical courses, leadership formation, and real conversations designed to help you live, lead, and love with purpose.
👉 Take the next step with us: